Guides · Process data

NOR, PAR and unlabelled ranges on batch records

A PAR (ICH Q8(R2)) is a range shown to give acceptable quality with the other parameters held constant. A NOR is the narrower band of normal operating variation inside it; ICH does not define it. Outside the NOR, a value departs from routine operation; outside the PAR, from the range shown to give acceptable quality.

Many batch records print two kinds of range beside a process parameter. The proven acceptable range (PAR) is the wider one: development or characterisation work has shown that running anywhere inside it, with the other parameters held where they should be, still gives material of the required quality. The normal operating range (NOR) is the narrower band the process is expected to stay in during routine manufacture. A value outside the NOR but inside the PAR means, where the NOR is the instruction, that the operator did not follow it, but the product is still on characterised ground. A value outside the PAR means it is not.

The difference matters twice: when a batch is reviewed (what kind of event is this?) and when the values go into a trend for continued process verification (which limit do you plot?). It also matters when a form prints a range with no label at all, which is common on older records.

What is a proven acceptable range?

The term comes from the glossary of ICH Q8(R2): a characterised range of a process parameter within which the process makes material meeting the relevant quality criteria, “while keeping other parameters constant”. That clause is the important part. A PAR is usually established one parameter at a time, and ICH Q8(R2) section 2.4.5 says plainly that a combination of PARs does not make a design space.

The European Medicines Agency’s Q&A on NORs, PARs and design space (2017) adds how a registered PAR behaves in a marketing authorisation:

  • a PAR allows a deliberate change in one parameter while the others stay at their NOR or target;
  • PARs can be presented in the manufacturing process description (Module 3, S.2.2 or P.3.3) and should be justified whether or not the parameter is critical;
  • working within an approved PAR is not a change to the dossier, and moving the target within it can be managed in the company’s quality system;
  • movement out of the PAR is a change and starts a post-approval change process.

What is a normal operating range, and who defines it?

No ICH guideline defines it. The EMA Q&A says so directly: “NOR is not an established ICH term.” It then describes a NOR as a region around the target operating conditions that contains common operational variability, the kind that cannot always be controlled. It is not meant to give flexibility in how the process is run, and it should not cover a range that affects the quality of the output. The EMA asks for NORs to be presented as what is practically achievable.

Outside that Q&A, NOR is an industry term. Each company defines it in its own procedures, usually from development data and from how tightly the equipment can hold a set point. The words differ too: “operating range”, “control range”, “target ± tolerance” and “alert limits” are all used for something close to a NOR. Your own procedures decide what the term means on your forms.

Aspect Normal operating range (NOR) Proven acceptable range (PAR) Design space
Defined by No ICH definition; EMA Q&A 2017 and company procedures ICH Q8(R2) glossary ICH Q8(R2) glossary
Based on Normal operational variability around the target Characterisation of one parameter, others held constant Multivariate studies of parameters and material attributes together
Purpose The band the process is run in Evidence that quality holds across the range Registered flexibility across interacting parameters
Moving outside it Departure from the instruction; handled under your quality system Outside the proven range; a registered PAR makes deliberate operation there a change Normally starts a post-approval change process (ICH Q8(R2))

How do the ranges appear on a batch record?

EU GMP Chapter 4 asks for processing instructions that include the critical process parameters (point 4.18(d)) and the in-process controls with their limits (4.18(e)). The batch processing record built from them records the results obtained and any deviation, with signed authorisation (4.20(f) and (h)). So the limits printed on the master batch record are usually copied into each executed record, and the operator writes the actual value beside them.

How they are printed varies by company and by the age of the form. Layouts you will meet:

  • two labelled columns, NOR and PAR, beside each parameter;
  • one range with the PAR in brackets: “60 to 70 °C (PAR 55 to 75 °C)”;
  • a target with a tolerance: “65 ± 5 °C”;
  • a one-sided limit: “NMT 75 °C” or “≥ 20 min”;
  • limits printed once above a table and applying to every row in it;
  • a single range with no label at all.
A NOR band inside a PAR band on a temperature scale A fictional inlet air temperature scale from 50 to 80 °C. The PAR runs from 55 to 75 °C, the NOR from 60 to 70 °C around a target of 65 °C. Reading A at 72 °C lies outside the NOR but inside the PAR. Reading B at 77 °C lies outside both. Proven acceptable range (PAR) 55 to 75 °C NOR 60 to 70 °C target 65 50 55 60 65 70 75 80 °C A 72 B 77
Illustration: a fictional inlet air temperature with a NOR of 60 to 70 °C inside a PAR of 55 to 75 °C. Reading A (72 °C) is outside the NOR but inside the PAR; reading B (77 °C) is outside both.

What does a value outside the NOR but inside the PAR mean?

Take reading A in the illustration. The product is still on characterised ground for that parameter, but only on the PAR’s terms: the evidence assumes the other parameters stayed at their NOR or target. If the same step also had a second parameter outside its NOR, the PAR studies may not cover that combination, and the assessment has to look at both.

The operator still ran outside the written instruction. Under 21 CFR 211.100(b) any deviation from written production procedures must be recorded and justified, and EU GMP Chapter 4 point 4.20(h) asks for signed authorisation of any deviation from the processing instructions.

How a company handles this varies, and the quality system decides. Routes companies use include, for example:

  • a minor deviation, assessed and closed with the PAR as the justification;
  • an event or excursion logged and trended, with a formal deviation only when it repeats or exceeds a set duration;
  • an alert in continued process verification, looked at for a drift even when each batch is acceptable.

Whatever the route, record which limit was exceeded, by how much and for how long, and whether any other parameter in the same step was also off target.

And a value outside the PAR?

Reading B is outside the range where quality has been shown. There is no characterisation data to lean on, so the deviation needs an investigation and a product impact assessment in its own right. 21 CFR 211.192 requires any unexplained discrepancy found in production record review to be thoroughly investigated, whether or not the batch has been distributed. Where the PAR is registered, the EMA Q&A treats deliberate operation outside it as a change to the authorisation, so check whether your procedures ask regulatory affairs to assess an excursion there as well.

How should you treat a range printed with no label?

An unlabelled range is the limit the operator was told to work to, so it is never meaningless. The question is whether it is a NOR, a PAR or something else, such as an in-process control limit or a specification.

  1. Look it up. The master batch record’s change history, the process description, the control strategy document or the process validation report usually say what the range is.
  2. If you cannot find out, treat it as the NOR. It is the narrower, more cautious reading. A value outside it gets looked at. Treating it as a PAR could let a value outside the real NOR pass without anyone noticing.
  3. Record the assumption beside the value, in the trend data as well as in the review, so whoever uses the data later knows the label was not printed.
  4. Fix the form. At the next revision, label every range. PIC/S PI 041-1 section 8.4 notes that ambiguous instructions may lead to inconsistent or incorrect recording of data.

What should go into your process data?

For trending, keep both limits beside each value rather than one “limit” column. The FDA process validation guidance names batch records among the sources for detecting variation in stage 3 (continued process verification), and asks that trending guard against overreaction to single events as well as against missing unintended variability. A value can be outside its NOR many times with every batch acceptable; the trend shows whether the NOR is still realistic or the process is drifting.

A checklist for each parameter you extract:

  • the value as written, with its unit;
  • the NOR and the PAR, each in its own column, and which one was printed;
  • whether a range was labelled or assumed;
  • the target, if one is printed;
  • the step and the page, so anyone can go back to the record.

Copying the limits is itself transcription and can go wrong in the same ways as the values; see decimal commas, units and dates. For building the dataset itself, see from batch records to CPV data. The glossary has the short definition of a proven acceptable range.

Sources

  1. ICH Q8(R2) Pharmaceutical Development (glossary; 2.4.5 Design Space Versus Proven Acceptable Ranges), accessed 18 November 2026.
  2. EMA, Questions and answers: Improving the understanding of NORs, PARs, DSp and normal variability of process parameters (EMA/CHMP/CVMP/QWP/354895/2017), accessed 18 November 2026.
  3. EudraLex Volume 4, Chapter 4: Documentation (4.18, 4.20), accessed 18 November 2026.
  4. 21 CFR 211.100 Written procedures; deviations, accessed 18 November 2026.
  5. 21 CFR 211.192 Production record review, accessed 18 November 2026.
  6. FDA, Process Validation: General Principles and Practices (2011), accessed 18 November 2026.
  7. PIC/S PI 041-1 Good Practices for Data Management and Integrity in Regulated GMP/GDP Environments (8.4), accessed 18 November 2026.

General information, not regulatory advice. Check the current text of each regulation; your quality system decides how it applies to you.

Related guides